An evidence-based battle for wildlife

An evidence-based battle for wildlife

Barbastelle bat (credit: Adi Ciurea)

A look into Dr. Charlotte Packman's research into barbastelle bats to understand the impact of a major road through the Wensum Valley.

Norfolk County Council will soon submit its planning application for the Norwich Western Link road. The coming spring will therefore be a vital time for us to speak up for the wildlife that depends on the tapestry of habitats threatened by the proposed route. 

Our two most powerful tools in protecting wildlife are accurate data and work in partnership with other bodies and the community. A solid base of evidence is crucial to effective conservation, whether we are improving habitat for wildlife or protecting a vulnerable landscape for its wild inhabitants.  

While the road will harm countless habitats and species, our research has focussed on the rare barbastelle bat, which is both legally protected and emblematic of the struggle to preserve the Wensum Valley. Growing evidence suggests that Norfolk holds vital strongholds for the barbastelle. 

Building a case for the bats, we are working with Dr Charlotte Packman, an experienced conservation scientist who has studied barbastelles in Norfolk for over a decade. To understand the impact of a major road through the Wensum Valley, Dr Packman has researched two key questions: the presence and activity of barbastelles in habitats along the route; and the effectiveness of measures put in place for bats along the existing Northern Distributor Road. 

Her findings are a stark warning to conservationists and developers alike, spotlighting the critical importance of Norfolk for this very rare bat and demonstrating that the Norwich Western Link would spell disaster for its survival. Dr Packman’s research has revealed the presence of many more barbastelles than Norfolk County Council ecologists have previously recorded, making the area even more important for the species. 

Dr Packman’s data suggest a minimum of 105 barbastelles are present in one of the maternity colonies. Norfolk County Council’s ecologists recorded just 27 barbastelles in the same colony. 

Her data also reveal the presence of a unique barbastelle super-colony in the area of the proposed road. The so-called super-colony comprises a number of large colonies of barbastelles and includes several woodlands supporting maternity colonies of vital importance to the survival of barbastelle bats in the UK. 

Norfolk is home to the majority of known barbastelle maternity colonies, making us the guardians of this species in the UK. 

Dr Packman’s data have also shown just how ineffective measures in place for bats along the existing NDR have been. This road development included structures known as bat bridges that, it was claimed, offered bats safe road crossings above vehicle height, from one area of habitat to another. Dr Packman’s data suggest that in fact barbastelles ignore these structures, preferring crossing points bordered by trees and overhanging vegetation, where they may be at risk from collision with vehicles. Alarmingly, her data suggest that barbastelle colonies present within 2.5km of the NDR prior to its construction have now disappeared. 

A map of the proposed NWL route

A map of the proposed NWL route

The area in red on the map shows the predicted impact on remaining barbastelle colonies, should the same outcome occur in the case of the Norwich Western Link. 

We have shared Dr Packman’s findings with Natural England, and we are pleased that, in response, the Wensum Woodlands have been added to a list of sites being considered for designation as SSSIs.  

Natural England’s criteria for designating a Site of Special Scientific Interest for barbastelles is the presence of a colony of 20 or more bats. 

Dr Packman’s research will continue this summer, as she gathers data in support of our opposition to plans for the Norwich Western Link. 

On account of the proposed road’s impacts on nationally significant wildlife, and to ensure an impartial decision is taken, we are calling for the planning application to be considered by the Secretary of State at a Public Inquiry.  

What can you do to help? 

Once the planning application for the road is submitted, a public consultation phase will follow. Please keep your eye on NWT emails and our social media for advice on speaking out in support of Norfolk’s wildlife, against this harmful development. 

-----------------------------------------------------------

To find out more about our campaign against the Norwich Western Link, please visit norfolkwildlifetrust.org.uk/ndr  

To hear Dr. Packman explain her research to the Bat Conservation Trust, listen to the BatChat Podcast here.